Yes, I've hooked everything up to my non-powered hub,...
Some thoughts -
Does your computer have more than 1 USB available? Try multiple USBs on computer, not through the hub.
You could have a bad HUB. Try a powered hub. Maybe your USB can't provide enough power for the NON powered hub.
Are you powering the Arduinos from a separate power supply? Again, the USB probably can not provide enough power to run them all.
Please show us the graphical channel mapping screens with the elements and the controller channels they are mapped to.